At a time when globalisation has profoundly transformed the way goods are produced and traded, value chains now span the entire planet, linking companies, suppliers and subcontractors in an unprecedented web of economic interconnection. Yet this complexity has a downside: it makes social and environmental impacts harder to trace, exposing companies to heightened risks of human rights violations, forced labour or environmental degradation. Against this backdrop, the concept of due diligence, or reasonable diligence, has emerged as a central instrument of corporate responsibility.
Rooted in international soft law, notably the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (2011), due diligence calls on economic actors to identify, prevent, mitigate and account for the adverse impacts of their activities on fundamental rights. It reflects a growing demand for consistency between economic performance and respect for universal values, particularly at a time when investors, consumers and States are calling for more responsible and transparent governance.
This approach now lies at the heart of international economic law and of the sustainable finance movement, which seeks to align financial flows with the Sustainable Development Goals. However, while due diligence is establishing itself as a key lever for transformation, putting it into practice across global value chains remains complex: the line between voluntary standards and legal obligations is still blurred.
- A central question therefore arises: to what extent is due diligence an effective tool for holding companies accountable in the light of international law and human rights?
I. The foundations and international scope of the duty of due diligence
1. The emergence of an international reference framework
Initially developed as an internal risk management tool within companies, due diligence has gradually been extended to the field of human rights in response to the ethical challenges raised by the globalisation of value chains. This development reflects the growing need to hold economic actors accountable for the social and environmental impacts of their activities, well beyond the purely financial sphere to which due diligence was once confined.
This shift crystallised with the adoption, in 2011, of the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (known as the “Ruggie Principles”). These rest on three pillars:
- the State duty to protect human rights,
- the corporate responsibility to respect them, and
- the need for effective access to remedy for victims.
Within this framework, due diligence is defined as an ongoing process of identification, prevention, mitigation and accountability in relation to potential human rights abuses.
In parallel, the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises reinforced this momentum by setting out practical recommendations for embedding due diligence in management policies, corporate governance and supplier relationships. Although they belong to the realm of soft law, these instruments have gradually shaped a genuine standard of conduct expected of economic actors worldwide.
2. From soft law to the emergence of binding obligations in value chains
Although due diligence was first promoted through instruments of soft law, it is now undergoing a process of juridification, marked by the transformation of voluntary recommendations into binding obligations for certain companies. This development responds to a recurring criticism of corporate social responsibility:
- as long as commitments remain optional, their effectiveness depends on the goodwill of economic actors, which limits their real impact in protecting human rights.
A major turning point came in France with Law No. 2017-399 of 27 March 2017 on the duty of vigilance. It requires companies with more than 5,000 employees in France (or 10,000 worldwide) to draw up and publish a vigilance plan covering their own activities, those of their subsidiaries, and those of the subcontractors and suppliers with which they have an established commercial relationship.
This plan must include:
- risk mapping, enabling potential abuses to be identified and prioritised,
- procedures for regularly assessing business partners,
- actions to prevent and mitigate the risks identified,
- a whistleblowing and reporting mechanism,
- a system for monitoring and evaluating the effectiveness of the measures implemented.
The law makes two key contributions:
- it imposes a legal duty of vigilance, rather than a mere incentive to act responsibly;
- it paves the way for a civil liability mechanism, allowing victims or NGOs, in theory, to take legal action for failure to comply with the duty of vigilance.
The TotalEnergies case in Uganda illustrates this: the company was taken to court in France over environmental damage and human rights violations linked to an oil project operated abroad. Although such litigation remains complex, it shows that the duty of vigilance can become a tool for holding multinationals legally accountable for acts committed within their value chain.
This French momentum is part of a broader European movement. The Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD), currently under revision, aims to harmonise due diligence obligations across the Union. It requires large companies operating in the European market, including foreign companies, to put in place procedures to identify, prevent, mitigate and, where appropriate, remedy serious adverse impacts on human rights and the environment across their global chain of activities.
At European level, the CSDDD introduces the concept of a duty of vigilance, and rests on four principles: responsibility, due diligence, transparency and remedy. The companies concerned will have to assess their own activities and those of their subsidiaries and business partners, implement measures to reduce risks, publish their results and remedy any harm caused.
It will initially apply to companies with more than 1,000 employees and a turnover exceeding €450 million, before being gradually extended to other companies and to certain non-European companies.
This shift from soft law to legal obligations thus marks a decisive step in turning due diligence into a genuine legal and operational standard of responsible governance at international level.
II. The challenges and prospects of implementation in global value chains
1. The practical and legal difficulties of implementation
Implementing due diligence in globalised value chains comes up against a number of structural and legal obstacles. These chains are often fragmented across several continents, with dozens of supplier tiers and sometimes thousands of companies. This complexity makes it difficult to define the sphere of influence of the lead company: how far must it know and control its supply chain?
The risks of human rights abuses are particularly high in these chains: forced labour, discrimination, degrading working conditions, environmental violations. The company’s reputation and legal liability are directly at stake. Due diligence therefore emerges as an essential tool, both for risk management and as a strategic lever, helping to protect the brand, secure supplies and strengthen long-term competitiveness.
However, the diversity of legal frameworks complicates the uniform application of these obligations. While some companies are subject to binding legislation, such as the French duty of vigilance law, the Sapin II Act (on combating corruption) or the European CSDDD, many are still bound only by voluntary commitments. This creates an uneven playing field and limits the overall reach of the framework.
Another major challenge concerns the nature of the due diligence obligation: it is an obligation of means, not of result. Companies must demonstrate that they have put reasonable measures in place to prevent human rights abuses, but they cannot guarantee that no violations will ever occur. This flexibility, which is needed to adapt to widely differing contexts, nevertheless opens the door to superficial practices, sometimes reduced to mere communication or compliance exercises (compliance washing).
Finally, access to justice for victims remains complex. Even when multinationals are based in Europe, proceedings remain lengthy and costly, and it is often difficult to establish the liability of parent companies for acts committed abroad, as the TotalEnergies case in Uganda has shown.
2. Towards effective integration of the duty of due diligence
Despite these challenges, encouraging trends show that due diligence is increasingly being integrated into corporate governance in a more systematic and strategic way.
Stronger regulation and standards
The introduction of a European legal framework through the CSDDD makes it possible to extend French standards to the entire European market. The directive requires companies to assess their entire value chain, including subsidiaries and partners, to prevent and mitigate risks, and to remedy any damage identified.
This preventive approach turns due diligence into a genuine governance criterion, compelling companies to integrate human rights and the environment into their strategies and decision-making processes.
Implementation methods and tools
Due diligence draws on a range of complementary methods:
- Risk mapping and assessment: identifying areas of vulnerability in the supply chain.
- Supplier questionnaires and audits: regularly checking compliance with ethical and social standards.
- Site visits and reputational checks: verifying partners’ actual practices.
- Internal whistleblowing mechanisms and ethics reporting: gathering critical information in real time.
Companies can thus detect potential violations at an early stage, enabling them to implement corrective measures: supplier training, stronger contractual clauses, enhanced audits or support to improve practices.
Real-world examples
- Patagonia: for several years, the company has been using independent audits, training programmes and supplier monitoring to ensure respect for human rights throughout its textile supply chain
- Danone: the company has built due diligence into its CSR policies and supplier contracts, requiring regular reporting of compliance indicators and sanctioning non-compliant partners.
- TotalEnergies (Uganda): illustrates the limits when due diligence is insufficient or difficult to monitor remotely, highlighting the role of civil liability and proactive vigilance.
Strategic dimension and sustainable finance
Due diligence is no longer merely a defensive tool: it has become a strategic lever. Investors and markets reward transparent, responsible companies that can demonstrate how they manage ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) risks. Effective implementation enhances reputation, facilitates access to finance and provides a competitive advantage, strengthening the resilience and sustainability of the value chain.
Implementing due diligence in global value chains remains complex, given fragmentation, obligations of means and the diversity of legal frameworks. Yet the combination of binding regulation, robust practical tools and an integrated strategic approach shows that the concept is becoming a genuine international standard of corporate responsibility, reconciling economic performance, respect for human rights and sustainability.
Main sources:
International texts & soft law
OECD – Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises (2023)
United Nations – Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (2011)
PRI (Principles for Responsible Investment) – Human Rights and Due Diligence in Investment (2021)
European Commission – Communication on sustainable corporate governance (2022)
Legislative & regulatory texts
Law No. 2016-1691 of 9 December 2016, known as “Sapin II”
Law No. 2017-399 of 27 March 2017 on the duty of vigilance of parent companies and ordering companies
Directive (EU) 2022/2464 of 14 December 2022 (CSRD)
Legal scholarship & practical guides
Deumier – Corporate social responsibility and the duty of vigilance, Revue des sociétés (2020)
EY – Human Rights Due Diligence Toolkit (2021)
Sherpa – Practical guide to the duty of vigilance (2022)
AFJE – Some recommendations on human rights due diligence (2021): https://www.afje.org/actualite/quelques-recommandations-en-matiere-de-due-diligence-portant-sur-les-droits-humains–257
Case law, case studies & NGO / corporate resources
CCFD-Terre Solidaire – Victory in the Total case (Uganda case) (n.d.): https://ccfd-terresolidaire.org/victoire-affaire-total-7218/
BHR – Friends of the Earth France and others v TotalEnergies SE (case summary) (n.d.): https://www.bhr-law.org/court-cases/friends-of-the-earth-france-and-others-v-total-energies-se
Patagonia – Working with Factories, Farms & Mills (n.d.): https://www.patagonia.com/working-with-factories-farms-mills/
Danone – Salient Human Rights Issues (2024): https://www.danone.de/content/dam/corp/global/danonecom/about-us-impact/policies-and-commitments/en/2024/danone-salient-human-rights-issues-march-2024.pdf
Photo by John Salvino on Unsplash



