Launched in 2019, the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) was intended to give investors a clear framework for comparing financial products on the basis of sustainability criteria. In practice, the distinction between the well-known Articles 6, 8 and 9 has served as a market classification, despite never having been designed as one, resulting in numerous grey areas, inconsistent use and risks of greenwashing.
Following several consultations and technical opinions, the European Commission is now preparing to propose a structural review of the SFDR. At the heart of the debate: the creation of a new official fund classification (with categories and minimum criteria), the introduction of a common sustainability indicator and closer alignment with the CSRD, the Taxonomy and the PAI indicators.
This reform, expected by the end of 2025, should mark a major turning point for European sustainable finance, clarifying the rules of the game and strengthening investor confidence.
What has happened so far – a new architecture taking shape:
Since its entry into force in 2021, the SFDR has quickly taken centre stage in the sustainable finance ecosystem.
Yet the distinction between so-called Article 6, 8 and 9 funds was never intended to be an official classification: these were first and foremost technical categories linked to disclosure obligations. In practice, these articles have been used as market labels, giving rise to opportunistic behaviour, legal uncertainty and inconsistent application by asset managers.
In response to these misuses, the European Commission launched a public consultation in 2023 and tasked its technical bodies with proposing solutions. Three key milestones have marked this process:
- The recommendations of the three European Supervisory Authorities (ESAs – EBA, ESMA, EIOPA) (June 2024):
- A proposal to create two voluntary categories for financial products:
- “Sustainable” funds, investing mainly in sustainable activities within the meaning of the Taxonomy and the SFDR definitions;
- “Transition” funds, incorporating strategies of transformation and gradual improvement.
- The introduction of a common sustainability indicator, expressed in a simple and comparable way and applicable to all financial products.
- A recommendation to test these new categories with retail investors before any roll-out, to ensure understanding and trust.
- A proposal to create two voluntary categories for financial products:
- The contribution of the EU Platform on Sustainable Finance (December 2024):
- A proposal for a slightly different architecture, with three categories:
- “Sustainable”, for products aligned with clear sustainability objectives and meaningful thresholds;
- “Transition”, for products supporting a measurable improvement pathway;
- “ESG Collection”, for products integrating ESG criteria without a strong commitment in terms of sustainability or transition.
- The introduction of an “unclassified” status for funds that do not fall into any of the three categories.
- The definition of minimum criteria (sustainable investment thresholds, exclusion of certain activities, compliance with DNSH and minimum safeguards).
- A proposal for a slightly different architecture, with three categories:
The European Commission’s roadmap (2025):
-
- In its work programme, the Commission confirmed that it would present a legislative proposal to revise the SFDR in the fourth quarter of 2025.
This review will draw on the ESAs’ recommendations, the Platform’s proposals and the results of the public consultations to define the new regulatory architecture.
-> This process points to a gradual convergence: the “Article 6/8/9” approach will be abandoned in favour of an official classification of sustainable financial products, structured around clear categories, with minimum criteria and a common sustainability indicator.
What to expect this autumn and through to the end of 2025
Autumn 2025 will be a pivotal moment for the SFDR reform. After more than two years of debate, the European Commission is on the verge of taking a decisive step.
- Finalising the impact assessment
-
- In spring 2025, the Commission launched a call for contributions (the “Call for Evidence”) to inform the impact assessment of the reform.
- This exercise aimed to measure the costs and benefits of a new official classification, to test different scenarios (2 or 3 categories, a mandatory or voluntary sustainability indicator) and to gather feedback from financial players, NGOs, national regulators and investors.
- The results are expected to feed into the final drafting of the legislative proposal.
- Expected trade-offs
Several key issues have yet to be decided:
-
- A two- or three-category architecture: the ESAs favour a simpler system (Sustainable / Transition), while the Platform wants to add an intermediate category (ESG Collection).
- Minimum thresholds and criteria: what percentage of sustainable investments will a fund need to qualify as “Sustainable”? Which indicators will be mandatory for “Transition” funds?
- Common sustainability indicator: its form (pictogram, score, numerical indicator) and whether or not it will be mandatory have yet to be defined.
- Link with other regulations: consistency with the CSRD, the Taxonomy and the PAI indicators is essential to avoid duplication and maximise the usefulness of the data.
Political timetable:
-
-
- October 2025: final internal discussions within the Commission, incorporating the views of the technical services and stakeholders.
- Q4 2025: publication of the proposal to revise the SFDR as part of the Commission’s legislative programme.
- Once adopted, the text will be sent to the European Parliament and the Council for review and negotiation (probably in 2026).
-
-> In practical terms, the coming months will be decisive: the Commission will have to strike a balance between simplicity, ambition and credibility, under pressure from two opposing camps:
- on one side, financial players calling for lower costs and clearer rules;
- on the other, NGOs and institutional investors advocating a demanding and robust classification, in order to limit greenwashing and maintain Europe’s leadership in sustainable finance.
Points to watch and implications for asset management companies
The SFDR review is not just a technical exercise: it will have direct impacts on the product strategy, communication and governance of asset management companies. Several points deserve particular attention right now:
- Anticipate the new classification
- The “Article 6/8/9” system is expected to disappear in favour of official categories.
- Each fund will need to be repositioned according to the new criteria (Sustainable, Transition, or other).
- This means re-examining the consistency between fund name, strategy and legal documentation to avoid any risk of mismatch.
- Align thresholds and criteria
- Even though the minimum thresholds (percentage of sustainable investments, sector exclusions, DNSH and social safeguard requirements) have not yet been finalised, it would be prudent to test different scenarios.
- Fund managers can already simulate portfolios under several threshold assumptions to identify funds “at risk” of being downgraded.
- Prepare for the sustainability indicator
- The introduction of a common sustainability indicator is almost certain.
- This will require stronger systems for the collection, consolidation and control of ESG data, in order to produce robust, auditable figures.
- Strengthen product governance
- The new categories are expected to come with more explicit and comparable criteria.
- Asset management companies will need to put in place clear fund validation processes, threshold monitoring and deviation management (escalation, communication, remediation).
- Communication and client relations
- Investors will need to understand the rationale behind the new classification.
- A clear, educational narrative will need to be prepared, explaining the difference between the old “Article 8/9” categories and the new ones, and clarifying what each term covers.
-> In short, the SFDR review is both an opportunity and a risk:
- An opportunity to strengthen the credibility and comparability of sustainable financial products.
- A risk if the transition is poorly anticipated, with funds being reclassified or clients losing confidence.
!! Timeline for the transition from the current classifications !!
- Today (2025)
-
- The Article 6, Article 8 and Article 9 categories remain fully in force.
- The Commission has acknowledged that this system is used as a market classification, even though it was not designed as such.
- Q4 2025
-
- The European Commission is due to publish its legislative proposal to revise the SFDR, which will include the new official fund classification (probably 2 or 3 categories).
- This proposal will officially signal the intention to end the use of Articles 6/8/9 as the reference system.
- 2026 – 2027
-
- Legislative negotiations (European Parliament + Council of the EU).
- Based on precedent (the original SFDR, the CSRD), it typically takes 12 to 24 months to reach an adopted text.
- 2027 – 2028 (estimate)
-
- If the revised regulation is adopted in 2026, phased application from 2027/2028 is the most likely scenario.
- Articles 6/8/9 would be gradually phased out and replaced by the new categories.
- A transitional period is almost certain (e.g. 1 to 2 years) to give asset management companies time to adapt their prospectuses, KID/PRIIPs documents and reporting.
Conclusion
The review of the SFDR marks an important milestone for the future of European sustainable finance, aiming primarily to bring to an end a period of legal uncertainty and lax practice.
By the end of 2025, the European Commission is set to present a new framework that should structure the market around official categories, with minimum criteria and a common sustainability indicator.
But the level of ambition has yet to be determined: between the desire for simplification expressed by some players and the need to preserve the integrity of the market in the face of greenwashing risks, the balance looks precarious.
For asset management companies, the challenge is twofold:
- anticipating the reorganisation of portfolios, documentation and communication,
- preparing to justify robustly the thresholds and commitments that will underpin the new classification.
-> The SFDR review will therefore be a real-world test of Europe’s ability to reconcile competitiveness, transparency and sustainability within a regulatory framework that is both demanding and workable.
! Key takeaways:
- There is no official date yet for the removal of Articles 6/8/9.
- The Commission will announce the exact timetable in its Q4 2025 proposal.
- Current signals suggest that Articles 6/8/9 will remain applicable until at least 2027, with a gradual switchover thereafter.
Our other articles on similar topics: SFDR – three years after its entry into force
Sources:
European Commission – Sustainable finance, Newsletter; https://finance.ec.europa.eu/news/sustainable-finance-2025-05-21_en
European Commission – Public consultation & Call for Evidence on the SFDR review; https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/14086-Standard-forms-for-the-publication-of-notices-in-the-field-of-public-procurement-eForms-3rd-Amendment_en
Joint ESAs (EBA, ESMA, EIOPA) – Opinion on the review of the SFDR framework (18 June 2024); https://www.esma.europa.eu/press-news/esma-news/esas-propose-improvements-sustainable-finance-disclosure-regulation
EU Platform on Sustainable Finance – Report on product categories and classification (17 December 2024); https://finance.ec.europa.eu/document/download/8a3d0e56-4453-459b-b826-101b1067290f_en?filename=241217-sustainable-finance-platform-proposal-categorisation-products_en.pdf
European Commission – Work Programme 2025; https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/strategy-documents/commission-work-programme/commission-work-programme-2025_en?utm_source=chatgpt.com
Photo by Mike Hindle on Unsplash



